My team and I have been fortunate to be involved in several very large infrastructure, energy and technology projects in South Africa over the past five years. These have included assisting overseas companies during the development of the Square Kilometre Array (SKA) telescope in the Northern Cape, working with international businesses involved in major renewable-energy projects such as wind farms and solar power plants, and, more recently, assisting companies participating in projects relating to the improvement and expansion of the Durban harbour.
These are very different projects, but from an immigration point of view, they present remarkably similar challenges.
Why large projects create challenges
Large infrastructure and industrial projects usually require the temporary deployment of significant numbers of foreign specialists. In many cases these are highly experienced engineers, technicians, commissioning specialists, project managers, equipment specialists and other technical personnel who have spent many years working with a particular technology or piece of infrastructure.
Importantly, their value does not always lie in having a master’s degree or another high academic qualification. Quite often, the more important factor is practical experience; their value lies in 15 or 20 years spent working on a particular turbine, control system, port installation, telescope component, manufacturing line or specialised piece of machinery.
That distinction is extremely important when we look at South Africa’s immigration legislation.
Our immigration system is generally designed around individual employment, rather than the temporary movement of large specialist teams required for a specific strategic project. As a result, the legislation does not always fit comfortably with the commercial reality of major infrastructure projects.
Typically, these projects require foreign specialists to come to South Africa for periods exceeding six months and, very frequently, to travel back and forth over a period of two or three years as the project moves through construction, installation, testing, commissioning, training and final handover.
Where existing framework falls short
The Short-Term Work Visa can be useful, but it has obvious limitations. According to the Department of Home Affairs’ interpretation, this authorisation can generally be issued for 90 days and extended once for a further 90 days, effectively limiting the individual to a maximum period of 180 days a calendar year. Visa requirements and policy interpretations may change over time and should always be assessed against the framework in force at the time of application.
Long-Term Work Visas are not necessarily an easy alternative either. Depending on the visa category involved, applicants may face comparatively high qualification requirements, lengthy processes associated with qualification recognition or other supporting documentation, and employment requirements that do not necessarily reflect the reality of international project work.
Frequently, the foreign specialist remains employed by the overseas manufacturer, engineering company or technology provider and is deployed to South Africa for a particular phase of the project. He or she may therefore never receive a conventional South African employment contract.
In my experience, immigration uncertainty can increase overall investment risk and project costs by reducing planning certainty. If a company does not know whether its commissioning engineers, turbine specialists or technical supervisors will be permitted to work in the country at the critical moment, that uncertainty inevitably has to be priced into the project.
If a company knows that it can bring the necessary specialists into South Africa when required, it can plan the project with considerably greater certainty.
Section 31(2) – an important, but often overlooked, mechanism
There is, however, a possible solution within the Immigration Act which is frequently overlooked. Section 31(2)(c) provides that, upon application, the Minister may, at their discretion and for good cause, waive any prescribed requirement or form.
The concept of “good cause” gives the Minister an important degree of discretion – in practical terms, it creates flexibility within immigration legislation which can be extremely useful where the normal visa framework simply does not accommodate the realities of a strategically important project.
We experienced this first-hand during our work connected with the Square Kilometre Array project. The international specialist provider involved understandably wanted to work with the same team of highly experienced technical personnel throughout important phases of the project. Constantly rotating specialists merely because an immigration permission had reached its maximum duration would have created additional cost and considerable inefficiency. Every replacement specialist would have required briefing, mobilisation, travel and accommodation. More importantly, continuity of knowledge would have been lost.
In the SKA matter, we were able to obtain a ministerial waiver relating to the limitation on extensions of the short-term work authorisation. This made it practically possible for the international provider to continue deploying the same specialists rather than constantly rotating personnel.
Other possible waiver applications
The same principle may also be applied to other requirements where there is a compelling project-specific justification.
In the past, for example, waiver applications have been used to address requirements connected with a SAQA evaluation. Where the qualifications of a large number of international specialists require evaluation, the additional administrative process can create substantial delays. If a five-month administrative process delays a critical project phase, the economic cost of the delay could vastly exceed any realistic benefit obtained from requiring the same documentation in exactly the same manner as for an ordinary work visa application.
Historically, we have also seen waiver applications considered where there was a compelling project-specific justification.
The detailed requirements applicable to General Work Visas have changed over time, including the introduction of the points-based system. However, the underlying principle remains important: where a statutory or regulatory requirement produces an unreasonable result in the context of a nationally significant project, Section 31(2) provides a mechanism through which the Minister may potentially exercise discretion – for example, The Minister could waive the compliance requirement listed on the scorecard, and thus only the usual personal documents, as well as an employment contract from the foreign employees, would be required for the application. The precise scope of any waiver application would depend on the applicable legislation, regulations and policy requirements in force at the relevant time.
The economic case must be properly demonstrated
A ministerial waiver should, of course, not become an easy way of avoiding normal immigration requirements. That would be a mistake. The strength of the mechanism lies precisely in the fact that it can deal with exceptional circumstances.
In our experience, it is therefore absolutely critical to demonstrate why the project is important to South Africa and why the presence of the foreign specialists is genuinely necessary.
A company should be able to explain the total investment value, the number of South African jobs being created or supported, the extent of local procurement, the value of technology or skills being transferred, the consequences of delaying the project and the reason the expertise cannot realistically be sourced locally within the required timeframe. Where applicable, the broader economic consequences should also be explained, for example:
- For an energy project, this could include additional generating capacity and the impact on energy security.
- For a port project, it could include increased cargo capacity, improved logistics efficiency and reduced costs for exporters and importers.
- For a major industrial project, it could include manufacturing capacity, exports, tax revenue and local supplier development.
- For a research project such as the SKA, the argument extends beyond the immediate construction work to South Africa’s international scientific reputation, research capability, technology development and ability to attract highly skilled researchers and future investment.
Local support is valuable
It is also important to address the obvious concern around employment opportunities for South Africans. If hundreds of foreign workers are required, stakeholders will understandably want to know why. That question should be answered directly rather than avoided.
The project should explain which positions require foreign expertise, why that expertise is unavailable locally, how long the foreign employees will remain in South Africa and, importantly, what programme exists for employing and training South Africans alongside them.
Support from local stakeholders can therefore be enormously valuable. Depending on the nature of the project, this may include local government, an organ of state, the relevant public entity, industry bodies, local communities and organised labour. Support from trade unions can be particularly persuasive where it demonstrates that organised labour itself understands that the temporary deployment of foreign specialists is necessary to unlock a much larger number of South African jobs.
There is therefore an opportunity, in my view, for project sponsors to consider whether a waiver application may be appropriate where genuine national importance can be demonstrated. The objective should not be to weaken immigration control. Rather, it should be to distinguish between ordinary employment migration and specialist mobility connected with major investments that create substantial economic value for South Africa. A carefully motivated ministerial waiver may provide additional flexibility in appropriate circumstances, subject to the Minister’s discretion and the facts of each case.
Written by Andreas Krensel, Senior Director, Africa and Europe, Envoy Global